Let’s put this out front, because for the next few weeks or even months a lot of people are going to try and pretend that this isn’t the reality:
Mitt Romney is the presumptive Republican nominee.
I wrote regarding Iowa:
At this point it is nearly impossible to fathom how he doesn’t get this nomination in a cakewalk. If you’re Team Romney, and guys like Gingrich and Perry have fallen away to a last-minute Santorum surge and a Ron Paul ~20% beachhead – you almost couldn’t write that script better. Mitt Romney not being the Republican nominee would be a collapse of historic proportions. He is more of a prohibitive favorite than any candidate in a non-incumbent primary in the last decade at least – in fact I can’t even think back to a time when a candidate’s path looked this much like a cakewalk.
You will not get this message from most mainstream sources or even political bloggers. I thought it was bleedingly obvious, but for some reason the coverage has been anything but “Mitt Romney running away with it.”
There are still interesting storylines to be sussed out, btw – most notably Ron Paul having staked out nearly a fourth of GOP voters as Ron Paul Republicans, which is pretty amazing when you think about it. But the competitiveness of the nomination is not one of them, nor is the prospect of anybody but Romney having a realistic shot at the nomination.
Sure I can caveat that – it goes without saying that nothing is outside the realm of possibility – but let’s face facts. As far as I’m aware there is not a single state in the union where Mitt Romney is not leading. He won Iowa despite only showing up in December. He is up 30 in New Hampshire. He is leading in South Carolina according to the latest post-Iowa polls (Rasmussen and PPP). The overwhelming likelihood is he wins Iowa, New Hampshire, and South Carolina – a nearly unprecedented opening running-of-the-table for a contested nomination race (and this considering that, in Iowa and South Carolina, he’s leading despite never having thrown himself into competing there). He has more money, establishment support, and organization than any other candidate by far.
His only remote competition, at this point, is a constantly-marginalized candidate who probably has a pretty hard ceiling of 25% (Ron Paul), and a candidate who is only in the conversation at all due to sheer, dumb luck (Santorum). The media will pretend that the Santorum “surge” says something about the Republican party, but really, Ezra Klein is right here:
Santorum’s finish doesn’t say much about his ideology, or his campaign skills, or his endorsements. Quite the opposite, in fact. In a race where a large number of anti-Romney voters were desperate to find a candidate, Santorum was unable to attract significant support until the very end, when the anti-Romney vote literally had nowhere else to go. If he had been a better candidate, he would have crested earlier.
Or, to use an analogy from Andrew Sullivan, the only reason Santorum is in this is because, in the game of musical chairs, he just happened to be the guy closest to the last empty chair when the music stopped. “In this game of musical chairs, if the music had stopped earlier, the nod would have gone to Newt or Ron. But that’s politics. Timing is everything.”
Think of it like Wheel of Fortune, with Sarah Palin, Donald Trump, Michelle Bachmann, Rick Perry, Herman Cain, Newt Gingrich, and Rick Santorum all being little more than segments of the wheel (for whatever reason, Paul, Huntsman, and Johnson have a different kind of niche). It just happened to be Santorum’s square that was there when the needle stopped.
Now, again, I’m not discounting the possibility of some non-Romney upsets. I see Ron Paul having a good chance of stealing some smaller states like Nevada, and the possibility of the anti-Romney forces freaking out and flocking to Santorum in enough numbers to bolster him to a few early wins in places like South Carolina is very real – perhaps even likely.
But besides Romney, the only candidate with a national campaign of any note is Ron Paul. And besides Santorum, there are no other ciphers left.
Jacob Weisberg puts it most bluntly:
We journalists are sorriest of all, because Romney coasting to victory is a weak story. Were the press any other industry, cynicism about its self-interest in promoting marginal challengers would prevail. Local television stations (many of them owned by media conglomerates such as Slate’s owner, the Washington Post Company) count on election-year revenue bumps from political advertising in important primary states. If the nomination contest is effectively over by, say, the time of the Michigan primary on Feb. 28, valuable money will be left on the table. But for reporters, rooting for the underdog, any underdog, is really a matter of wanting a more dramatic story. The straight-laced front-runner winning Iowa and New Hampshire before securing the nomination early on does not count as a compelling narrative. Hence the media’s pretense of taking seriously a succession of nonviable candidates with outlandish views. Rick Santorum is not, under any circumstances, going to be the GOP nominee.
Advertisement
This confluence of motives amounts to an insider conspiracy to resist the obvious.
So expect to hear more and more about less and less likely alternatives to a Romney victory in the coming weeks. Jon Huntsman, the only candidate yet to enjoy a moment of popular enthusiasm, could do better than expected in New Hampshire. Once Rick Perry joins Michele Bachmann in dropping out, conservative sentiment could coalesce around the unlikely survivor Rick Santorum.* Chris Christie could still change his mind! Anything could happen, of course, but it won’t. In the end, the GOP is overwhelmingly likely to nominate Romney because he is the most electable candidate available and at this point, no one else can beat him.
So rather than a lot of thought given over to Rick Santorum or this or that nuance of the contest for distant second (again, save Ron Paul, which is interesting if not necessarily relevant to the contests of 2012), the electoral reality we live in is a Barack Obama vs. Mitt Romney race for the Presidency. If you need to ponder or conjecture something, it should be that.